This is a @glynmoody must-read: Mobile provider Three (ie: 3 UK) are indulging in political censorship.

Sorry, did we say “political censorship?” – we meant “anything they class as mature content“.

Remember that the mandatory filtering proposal was meant to be protecting children from sex? Well…

Here’s yet another worrying example of that problem, this time involving the UK operator 3UK, pointed out by Nick Rothwell. Pride’s Purge is a Web site described by its creator Tom Pride as “an irreverent look at UK politics”. As he recently discovered, it’s also blocked by 3UK’s child protection filter. He contacted the company on Twitter, pointing out that Pride’s Purge was not a porn site or anything similar, and this is what it replied:

We don’t just block adult websites, websites with mature content may also be censored.

So it now seems that there is a category of material called “mature content” that is distinct from “adult content”, and that is also blocked by child protection filters, at least on 3UK’s network. Worryingly, political satire seems to be regarded as an example of “mature content”, and therefore unsuitable for children under 18. In fact, the censorship is even worse, as Pride explains:

it’s not blocked for just the under-18s. It’s blocked for anyone who hasn’t proven to [3UK] they are over 18 — and that means you will have to give your full identity to 3UK before they allow you to enter this site.

Which means 3UK now officially regard political satire as porn — and are censoring it in exactly the same way.

This very broad, default censorship is disturbing for at least two reasons. First, because many people will be unaware that this kind of “mature content” censorship is taking place at all, and therefore won’t ask for it to be stopped. And secondly, even if they are aware, the fact that asking for the filter to be lifted could be seen as tantamount to wanting to access porn — something that many will understandably be reluctant to have noted down on their Internet access record — means that they will simply put up with a limited feed. And so the creeping, silent censorship of the mobile Internet not only continues, but probably gets worse in the absence of any significant pushback against it.

The full post is at Techdirt; see also Pride’s Purge - if you can.

3 thoughts on “This is a @glynmoody must-read: Mobile provider Three (ie: 3 UK) are indulging in political censorship.

  1. Dave Walker

    Hmm, so much wrongness, in so many ways…

    * shouldn’t interest in politics be encouraged rather than censored, given current voter apathy?
    * are political satirists necessarily “mature”?
    * come to that, are all *politicians* necessarily “mature”? ;-)
    * is satire of all politicians being censored equally, or is there a party bias?

    Need I go on?

    (Hmm… on the “flexible porn” thing, I don’t have a 3 subscription, so I can’t test whether they’ve blocked http://www.astonmartin.com/ …)

    Reply

Leave a Reply